Update · Thu, Nov 19
Anthropic's $81 billion IPO, and why "cheap" Nvidia is not the same as Nvidia
Anthropic began trading today on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT. It sold 980 million shares at $83, above its first range of $70 to $78, and raised about $81.3 billion. That is the largest IPO on record, at a value of roughly $1.4 trillion to $1.5 trillion depending on the share count used. Gray-market trading had pointed to a first trade as much as 27% above the offer price.
The first trade came at 11:48 a.m. ET at $111.50, 34% above the $83 offer and above what the gray market expected. It touched $114.99 in the first minutes and was about $111.90 just before noon. That is the boom part of my call. The hold and the bust are still ahead.
What the filing shows. Anthropic reported $17 billion of revenue in the third quarter and $9.9 billion of computing cost, so about 58 cents of every revenue dollar goes to compute. Government work is under 2% of revenue. Reuters, reporting on the prospectus, counted at least $518 billion of computing commitments over about ten years, most of it payable whether or not Anthropic uses it.
The tie to Nvidia. Alongside the IPO, Anthropic is selling about $26 billion of stock privately to its suppliers and partners: Nvidia and Google about $10 billion each, AMD $2.5 billion, and Broadcom, Micron and Microsoft about $1 billion each, as reported from the amended filing. So yes, the IPO helps Nvidia directly: its biggest customers get cash to keep buying. But read the circle. Suppliers put money in, and much of it comes back as chip orders. And Anthropic does not run only on Nvidia. It also runs on Amazon's Trainium chips and Google's TPUs. The IPO money is spread across several chip makers.
My read on the IPO, on the record before the first trade: boom, hold, bust, then hold at a fair price, the same path I think SpaceX took. People who could not get into Anthropic privately get their chance today, and that demand can carry the first days. The real test is whether revenue keeps outrunning computing costs. I also think the company that wins government work wins this race, the way Palantir built its business on governments and enterprises instead of consumers. Today that business is under 2% of Anthropic's revenue. I will score the call at 1, 5, 20 and 60 trading days.
Now Nvidia. People are calling it cheap at under 10 times earnings. That is true on analysts' estimates for next year. On what it earns right now, it is about 14 times: $152 a share against about $10.72 of yearly earnings at last quarter's pace. Either way, it is far below where it traded this summer.
The level I watch is $148 to $150. On November 12, the day Huang resigned, Nvidia touched $148.80 in the first minute of trading and closed at $166.19, up almost 12% from that low. This week it bottomed at $150.33 on Tuesday. Today it rose to $158.13 at the open and gave most of it back, to about $152 by noon, still above the zone. Buyers keep showing up in that zone. If it breaks below $148 and stays there, that tells me the cheap price is not cheap enough, and that the market is repricing Nvidia without its founder.
My read: cheap does not mean it is worth what it was. Jensen Huang was part of the price. If the market decides the founder premium is gone, the low multiple is the new normal, not a bargain. And if Nvidia, the leader, is priced like this, other chip names may come down to match it. The prices fit the idea so far. From the November 12 close to noon today, Nvidia fell 8.6%, Micron 9.6%, Oracle 9.7%, TSMC 10.7% and AMD 15.0%. Broadcom held up best, down 1.4%. That is consistent with my read, not proof of it.
The scorecard from Tuesday. I said a beat "won't mean anything." Wednesday, Nvidia closed down 2.9% at $150.96 while the chip index finished flat, up 0.1%. That call was a hit. The other side of the record, that proof the business is unchanged could spark a relief rally, missed on day one.
So far the IPO has not lifted Nvidia. It opened up 2.2% and was up only 0.7% at noon, after Anthropic began trading. AMD was down 6.2%, while the chip index was up 1.4%. One possible reason, my read and not proven: some money is moving out of chip stocks and into Anthropic itself. What I watch: ANT's first trade and close, whether chip stocks hold their gains into the close, and the Fed. Governor Waller said this week that a half-point hike in December should be on the table.
Research and opinion, not investment advice.
ANT · NVDA · AMD · AVGO · GOOGL · AMZN
